Mike_E_from_NZ
18-06-2006, 04:23 PM
Just a quick reply to your comments about copyright, Mark.
I think there are a few things that have to be very right in the beginning of a project like this. Whilst this is a project 'by the people', for it to be successful the foundations do have to be very solid.
Copyright is a (unfortunately) hot topic these days and everyone needs to know where they stand.
If you have a look at the copyright notice you will see that Murray has chosen (and I have outlined) a strategy that keeps the content as free as possible. If we left it alone (as you have suggested) then, by default, the most restrictive copyrights become applicable. And then the content becomes less useful to permaculturalists (who by their nature are budding anarchists).
And by choosing this strategy, Murray has also made it possible for anyone to go to any other resource that uses the same strategy and use some of their material - far beyond what might be considered "fair use" if any other strategy was selected.
In other words, these pages are necessary to enable a Permapedia to be 'by the people'.
No, this is not a law manual - but by applying these copyright terms we are making sure that Murray (and any contributor) doesn't waste their future time reading them. (Witness lawsuits in the US now, against people who have innocently exercised rights that have been taken away by corporations who just hate open source material)
Mike
I think there are a few things that have to be very right in the beginning of a project like this. Whilst this is a project 'by the people', for it to be successful the foundations do have to be very solid.
Copyright is a (unfortunately) hot topic these days and everyone needs to know where they stand.
If you have a look at the copyright notice you will see that Murray has chosen (and I have outlined) a strategy that keeps the content as free as possible. If we left it alone (as you have suggested) then, by default, the most restrictive copyrights become applicable. And then the content becomes less useful to permaculturalists (who by their nature are budding anarchists).
And by choosing this strategy, Murray has also made it possible for anyone to go to any other resource that uses the same strategy and use some of their material - far beyond what might be considered "fair use" if any other strategy was selected.
In other words, these pages are necessary to enable a Permapedia to be 'by the people'.
No, this is not a law manual - but by applying these copyright terms we are making sure that Murray (and any contributor) doesn't waste their future time reading them. (Witness lawsuits in the US now, against people who have innocently exercised rights that have been taken away by corporations who just hate open source material)
Mike